This meme was started by Books by Proxy, whose fabulous idea was to compare UK and US book covers and decide which is we prefer. This meme is being nurtured by Lynn’s Book Blog and this week we are featuring covers with FAE. I’ve selected The Darkest Part of the Forest by Holly Black.
This is the default cover design, produced by Little, Brown Books in January 2015. I like this one – the treatment of the font, with the forest almost growing out and around the lettering is striking, while that blue butterfly really pops. It works especially well in thumbnail and is well balanced, while providing an appropriate mood and atmosphere for the book. This is a strong, successful cover.
Published in February 2015, by Indigo – what a difference a colour makes! The same design as the previous offering, except for the background colour. I think this throws the lettering into even sharper focus and gives a cover a real feel of the dark, enclosed forest. While the previous cover is well designed, I think this one is better – and I so very nearly went for this one…
This German edition, published in April 2017 by cbt has broken away from the default cover to give us a representation of the main teenage protagonists. Along with the mysterious forest that encompasses their story… Initially, I thought this was a bit cheesy – but the sheer attention to detail, with the deep forest, the wolf on one shoulder, the eagle circling above and the girl appearing from a forest thicket on his other shoulder – has made me a lot more appreciative of the overall design. I particularly like the roots at the bottom of the image, with bits of the soil still falling, as if it has just been yanked out of the ground.
Published by Galera Record in March 2017, this Portuguese edition is a bit more generic, with some stylised flowers and butterflies adorning the cover. While it is certainly attractive and eye-catching, I find it bland and ordinary in comparison to the previous covers. My favourite part of this cover is the quirky title and author font, which I really like and immediately elevates this design into something more original.
This Russian edition, published in 2016 by ACT, is my favourite. I find that fae staring straight out at us is mesmerising. The ears and horns superimposed on that beautiful head makes it difficult for me to look away from his unusually coloured eyes. I love the detailing of the rich fabric, even on the highly embroidered lining, along with the brocade background of the forest. I haven’t read this one – but this is the cover that makes me want to track it down and add it to my teetering TBR list. While this is my favourite, which one do you prefer?
Such interesting covers, Sarah! I like the very first one the best for many of the ideas you mention. I prefer it over the similar second one because of the overall darkness and lack of color, except for the beautiful butterfly.
Lol… that’s why I like this meme so much, Becky! There isn’t a right or wrong – and I can never forecast which cover people will go for:)).
I love the last one too! The “in your face” presence of the fae is so attention grabbing!
I know! And I’m not always a huge fan of seeing protagonists splashed across book covers – but that was just so very well done…
Love all the covers , but the very first one is my favourite
Thank you, Rash:). It’s a really strong design, isn’t it?
I like the first one: the lack of background color makes that gorgeous blue butterfly stand out more 🙂
Thank you Maddalena – the butterfly certainly stands out more on the top cover. I am just amazing at how different the covers look when you add a colour to the background…
I haven’t read this but all the covers are rather pretty, except maybe the last one, which is a little too unsubtle about the whole fae thing for me! 😄
I know! And generally I prefer subtle, too. But this time around… he is just so beautiful and DIFFERENT. Perhaps that’s why I like it so much:)
I have owned this forever but not read it (yet). I love Holly Black’s fae tales and was tempted to go with Tithe but think I’ve already used it. I love your choice, it’s so unusual and striking. And, I like the first because it has a dark and ominous tone.
Lynn 😀
It certainly does… Thank you for a lovely theme – I had great fun tracking this one down.
Again, I am not familiar with this story, but based on what attracts my eye, I liked the first one.
Glad you liked the first one, Carla – as ever, I am always intrigued by people’s favourites:))
I like the first one.
I can’t choose. I like all of them this time.
Oh my, the German edition is my favorite!
Hmmm…I actually like that second one the most. You are so right about that background color–it reminds me of a freshly-sawed tree trunk with a bit of bronzing for shine. 🙂
Thank you, Jean – it is a fabulous colour, isn’t it?
Yes! Like a bronze sword, almost.