Friday Faceoff – Four eyes are better than two… #Brainfluffbookblog #FridayFaceoffglassescovers


This meme was started by Books by Proxy, whose fabulous idea was to compare UK and US book covers and decide which is we prefer. This meme is being nurtured by Lynn’s Book Blog and this week we are featuring covers with GLASSES. I’ve selected My Sister, the Serial Killer – by Oyinkan Braithwaite.

Doubleday Books 2018

This edition was produced by Doubleday Books in November 2018. I think it is a fabulous cover. The woman on the front is sublimely beautiful and yet we cannot fully connect with her, because of those sunglasses – which reflect a raised hand clutching a knife. So clever! While that catchy title pings off the cover in a luminous green that makes me wonder why more cover designers don’t use it. This is the default cover and my favourite.

Alpha Decay 2019

Published in November 2019 by Alpha Decay, this Spanish edition isn’t nearly so successful. The manner in which we are prevented from fully connecting with the strong young woman on the cover is far clumsier. While those tiny textboxes are making a poor job of highlighting the title and author, while at the same time further disrupting the cover design.

العربي للنشر والتوزيع January 2020

This Arabic edition, published by العربي للنشر والتوزيع in January 2020, demonstrates why I hate textboxes so much. The woman featured on the cover is even more mysteriously alluring than the one adorning the Doubleday edition. I love the colours of her headscarf and the bold, blue lipstick – and they have the good sense to hold onto those marvellous sunglasses. Then they go and ruin it by covering up a quarter of that marvellous image with a mustard-coloured textbox! Worse, they plaster another charmless effort right across her forehead… Otherwise, this design would have been a real contender.

Kapulana 2019

This Portuguese edition, produced by Kapulana in April 2019, has done away with beautiful girls wearing sunglasses – and instead gives us the CSI version. We have a cover featuring some of the utensils necessary for getting rid of a body. The bright yellow font nicely pops from the reddish brown background – the colour of drying blood? But I personally still prefer the first offering.

This Macedonian edition, published by Антолог in 2020 is back to poised beauty hiding behind those sunglasses reflecting the stabbing knife. This time, the image has been given the graphic novel treatment, which I think works really well. I love the shading and the fact we see more of her neck and shoulders. I also love the grimy yellow background and bold, tilted treatment of the title font, with the author’s name featured along the top. This is a classy, sophisticated cover that so very nearly got my vote… but which is your favourite?

28 responses »

  1. Pingback: The Friday Face-Off: Spectacular – Books by Proxy

  2. My favourite is definitely the Doubleday cover with the Macedonian edition coming in a very close second! Both gorgeous! 😀

    And while I love the image of the blue lipsticked woman on the Arabic cover, the glasses appear to have been drawn on her face!

  3. The default one is also my favorite, but I like the Arabic one too! Nice pick! I also went with the sunglasses. I chose Where’d you go Bernadette. Loved that book.

    Hope you will have a great weekend. Here’s my Weekend Book Friends

    • Thank you, Mareli. I’ll nip across and check out your choice – this week has been so much fun because everyone has chosen such a different range of books:)).

      Thank you! I hope you, too, have a wonderful weekend.

    • I love taking part in this meme, Diana. It always behoves indie authors to pay attention to what makes covers successful, I think:). And you’re right – it’s also great fun!

  4. I totally agree with both your first and second choices Sarah. The Arabic cover would turn me off this book completely. There is so much I dislike about that one.

  5. I never would have picked up the reflection in the sunglasses – excellent touch. I love your choice and the Macedonian cover. Probably on edge he Macedonian just wins the day for me with it’s graphic novel type feel.
    Lynn 😀

    • It is a cool touch, isn’t it? I hadn’t noticed the reflection until I magnified the covers – and then this book was the obvious choice for this week’s theme:)). And I agree that the Macedonian cover is a really cool one:).

  6. WOAH! I totally missed the knife in the sunglasses until you mentioned it! That’s a killer detail (ba dum CH) that really takes the first offering over the top. The non-girl cover is…hmmm. IT just feels like another cozy mystery, you know? There’s nothing to make that stand out. Meh.

    • Yes – you have nailed it, Jean. There is nothing wrong with the non-girl cover – but it simply cannot compete when put against the girl in those sunglasses…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.