*NEW RELEASE SPECIAL* Review of NETGALLEY arc The Pursuit of William Abbey by Claire North #Brainfluffbookreview #ThePursuitofWilliamAbbeybookreview #WyrdandWonder2020


I enjoy Claire North’s writing – see my reviews of The Sudden Appearance of Hope, Touch and The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August. So I was delighted when I was approved to read this intriguing offering. I will be linking this review to the Wyrd and Wonder 2020 event, featuring all kinds of fantasy.

BLURB: South Africa in the 1880s. A young and naive English doctor by the name of William Abbey witnesses the lynching of a local boy by the white colonists. As the child dies, his mother curses William. William begins to understand what the curse means when the shadow of the dead boy starts following him across the world. It never stops, never rests. It can cross oceans and mountains. And if it catches him, the person he loves most in the world will die.

Every book North has written under this current pen name – see my review for A Madness of Angels – Book 1 of The Midnight Mayor by Kate Griffin – has ostensibly been a standalone. However, there is a theme developing here. Individuals who, by luck or some kind of genetic predisposition, find themselves coping with an unusual trait that takes them beyond everyday life and into the realms of the paranormal. William is another of these unfortunates – having been cursed for being in the wrong place at the wrong time – and when his shadow approaches, he divines the truth of those around him. And as his shadow gets ever closer, he is forced to babble that truth aloud.

This adventure stretches from the 1880s, and ends in 1914 in a field hospital during World War I, so you won’t be surprised to discover that it isn’t long before William’s unique ability draws down attention from the British Empire intelligence services and their department Nineteen. In return for keeping William on the move, so that his shadow is never able to completely catch up with him, he goes where they send him and learns the truth from ambassadors, princelings, other agents all around the world. It gives North an ideal opportunity to chart some of the political shenanigans that goes on during that turbulent time, which she does in impressive detail.

This is, indeed, an impressive book. The prose is impassioned and elegant, the character caught up in a horrible situation so that he is so far out of his comfort zone, he is almost drowning. And yes, if you’re sensing a but, you’re right. I didn’t really like William all that much. I didn’t like anyone all that much. While I sympathised with him intellectually, I simply found him too annoyingly wet and steeped so deeply in his own self-loathing, that I was unable to truly bond with him. And that’s a real shame, because the book is a magnificent achievement. I don’t think I’ve encountered a more impassioned and literate critique of our social value system, both then and now.

I just wish there had been a few more shafts of light and humour, which I know North is capable of writing brilliantly – because by the time I was two-thirds of the way through this one, I was conscious that I’d become a bit numbed to the ceaseless acts of violence against the poor and powerless. That might just mean I’m a really shallow person, but my sense is that if that burning anger against the social injustice of the capitalist, elitist mindset had been just a bit less intense, then there would have been room for me to jump on board, too. I’m also not a fan of the ending.

I’m conscious this sounds like one long moan – but if someone offers me the chance to read her next book, I’ll take it like a shot. North is a remarkable talent, who sees the world in a particular way and although I often find the journey alongside her uncomfortable, there is too much to admire to want to miss it. Recommended for fans of magic realism adventures with a literary edge. The ebook arc copy of The Pursuit of William Abbey was provided by the publisher through NetGalley in return for an honest opinion of the book.

9 responses »

  1. I’ve only read (or tried to read, I never finished it) one book from North, 84K. It was too dense and confusing for me, unfortunately. But I’ve heard wonderful things about some of her books and I’d love to give her another chance. Lovely review, Sarah!

  2. I wonder if the unlikable character was designed to be this way, and not just because of your reader’s perception. And I understand what you mean about excessive exposure to violence and injustice: when authors try too hard to drive a concept home, they usually spoil their own efforts…
    Thanks for sharing! 🙂

  3. Hmmm. You know, Bo and I were just having a talk about the need for humor and positive chemistry over the meaner, more cringey events. Granted, this was when talking about The Office vs. Parks and Recreation, but I wonder if the same point applies: when you have a positive chemistry among the characters, the occasional darkness is necessary and appreciated for engagement; if you have negative chemistry, where characters are CONSTANTLY in mean, dire, just dark places, you really do get numb to it. I think that makes sense?….As the Jedi would say–balance, you must have. 🙂 xxxx

    • Yes – absolutely! And it’s such a shame that there wasn’t those flashes of light. This is a really intense, angry book and I understand why and respect those reasons. But I still end up feeling a bit distanced by it. There’s a saying about not being able to appreciate the light without the dark – I think the opposite also applies…

  4. Mmm, this is another of those books that I debated but then decided I didn’t have enough time to squeeze it in and given that you didn’t really like the characters I’m thinking that might be a good choice for me – even if the writing sounds lovely.
    Lynn 😀

    • Yes – I know what you mean… Her ideas are spell-binding, but given she is on the literary side of the genre, she opts these days to go for slightly unsympathetic characters, which I find difficult to really care about.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.