This meme was started by Books by Proxy, whose fabulous idea was to compare UK and US book covers and decide which is we prefer. This meme is being nurtured by Lynn’s Book Blog and this week we are featuring covers with BIG DRESSES. I’ve selected These Broken Stars – Book 1 of the Starbound series by Amie Kaufman and Meagan Spooner.
This edition was produced by Disney Hyperion in December 2013. It’s a gorgeous cover and has become, quite rightly in my opinion, the default cover for this book. That dress is just beautiful – the colour sublime and wonderfully sets off her titian hair. I love the richness and sheer volume of those skirts and the way her hair also moves as she stretches up to him. And there are stars… *sighs with pleasure*. The problem with this cover is that the title font just disappears, being far too slight to prevail against the action and colour of the cover.
Published in May 2016 by Carlsen, this German cover is not a bad effort. The two faces both looking out at us are eye-catching and again, the starscape appearing through the main image is effective and gives us a real clue as to the genre. However, while I like the attractive style of the font – it’s the wrong colour, being far too close to the skin tones of the faces behind it, so it essentially disappears when in thumbnail.
This Portuguese edition, published by Editora Planeta in December 2015, is featuring the romance far more heavily, while also giving us a taste of the alien planet below. Split image covers like this can work as long as the divide is effective, which I think it is in this case. I think while the font works for a romance, it isn’t so successful if you take into account the sci fi element. However, the problem for me is that the kissing couple is not something that would induce me to pick up the book.
This French edition, produced by La Martinière Jeunesse in December 2013, is more heavily leaning towards the sci fi element – you won’t be surprised to learn that this was a very close contender for me. I like the tension evident on the protagonists’ faces and the punchy font, as well as the clearly alien nature of the landscape featured across the top half of this cover.
This paperback edition, published by Allen & Unwin in December 2013 is my favourite. It is essentially the top cover, with all the lushness and loveliness AND you can read the book’s name, which has to be a bonus😊. Which is your favourite?
I definitely agree with your favourite – it would have been the first cover but you really have to try hard to make out the title of the book.
Lynn 😀
Yes – and that rather defeats the purpose of a book cover, doesn’t it?
Great choice! I have to say that because I picked the same book😁 And I agree with your choice, it’s so hard to read the font in the first book, but who can resist that beautiful green dress!
Lol… you know what they say about great minds, don’t you? And that is just THE most fabulous dress…
I also vote for your choice, as well, Sarah. Such a great cover!
Thank you, Becky:). The moment I caught sight of this cover, I knew I had to feature it. I now need to lever the book into my reading schedule…
I love your breakdowns of what do and don’t work on each cover.
Thank you, Kristen – though of course it’s highly personal… and gives me a chance to have a rant about my own peeves regarding covers!
It definitely is the default/best cover–all those folds of aqua! Magnificent!
Thank you, Rae – it is sumptuous, isn’t it?
The design alone…wow!
I definitely agree with your choice Sarah. I love the colours, it sure attracts my eye.
It really is so pretty! I’m glad you also love this one, Carla.
I think the bottom is my favorite too with the first being a close second. That cover with the stars and the colors is just too gorgeous. I remember when it came out and I wanted to read it just based on the cover alone!
Oh yes – it has me itching to reach for it too, Katherine:)
I just came from Tammy’s blog and I agree with you both, the “dress” cover is the best!
Yes – it was really funny to see that Tammy had chosen the same cover as me:).
Yes, the last one is indeed perfect: with the smaller font one can better appreciate that *gorgeous* dress… 🙂
Thank you, Maddalena:). It is also a bonus that the font doesn’t disappear in thumbnail!
Your pick is my favorite too. I love those gorgeous colors with the backdrop of stars and space. I also like the font on this one better than the other variation of the same cover.
Thank you, Suzanne – yes, I think it’s an improvement. It’s surprising what a difference varying font styles makes.
My favorite is the 2013 paperback edition.
Oh yes – it is lovely, isn’t it?
Yes! 🙂
I see what you mean about the dress! I do love that font on the eyeball cover, though. What would you think if that title font was used on the dress cover?
You’re right – that would be the best of all worlds, wouldn’t it?