This meme was started by Books by Proxy, whose fabulous idea was to compare UK and US book covers and decide which is we prefer. This meme is currently being nurtured by Lynn’s Book Blog and the subject this week featuring on any of our covers is EXPLOSIONS. I’ve selected Cibola Burn – Book 4 of The Expanse series by James S.A. Corey – see my review of Leviathan’s Wake. I’ve also linked this week’s meme with @SciFiMonth2019, given this epic space opera series is such a success.
This edition was produced by Orbit June 2014. I love the big, blockbuster feel of this cover, which really suits the feel of this large-scale epic space opera series. This is the default cover from which many of the others are derived – and with good reason, given the drama it engenders. I also like a punchy orange title font and the large blocky design, giving a slightly retro feel to the book design. This is my favourite – it looks good both full-sized and in thumbnail.
Published in November 2018 by MAG, this Polish edition has opted for a completely different feel. Gone is the large space station, the flaming debris from a disintegrating ship – we don’t even have a distant nebula or starscape to relieve the ink-black background. There is just a drifting astronaut with a bunch of cables… In thumbnail, you cannot make out what is going on – and given this was only released last year, that is a fundamental error. The feeble font is all but eaten up by that black background and certainly doesn’t prevail once the cover is shrunk. I think this is bleak and boring.
This Serbian edition, published by Laguna in June 2016, is more like it! I love the way the central artwork is highlighted with that dramatic red backdrop, so those tentacles waving in the air take centre stage. The lightning streaking through that awesome title font is also a lovely touch, as it the nifty little shuttle perched on the rocky outcrop off to the left. Overall, I really like the eye-catching drama of this offering – a huge improvement on that previous dreary effort. It is so nearly my favourite…
This Italian edition has gone back to the original cover for inspiration, enlarging that exploding piece of space debris and making the title a bit funkier. I think this gives the cover extra visual drama, as that blazing explosion really stands out, but it is at the expense of the monumental scale of the original cover, which I think works better. Though it’s SUCH a close-run thing… ask me tomorrow and I’ll probably vote for this one, instead.
This Russian edition, published in June 2018 by Эксмо: fanzon is also another cover which offers an epic overview of a dramatic space battle. The colours are more muted, but I love the artwork and I think the scene is beautiful. The detail of the dreadnaught in the centre of the cover is fabulous. However, while I absolutely love it as a piece of artwork, I don’t think it ticks enough boxes as a cover. In thumbnail, once again, it’s too dark. And the title and author fonts fail to sufficiently stand out. Which is your favourite?
I prefer the red and black Siberian edition. It offers a strong feeling of heat!
It certainly does:).
Ooh great choice this week😁 For me, I think the Serbian edition wins by a hair. I also love the first one. I really love all the bright colors!
Yes – it is a very close-run thing between those two, isn’t it?
I considered using an Expanse cover for this theme as well! I just adore the Orbit covers.
Ah… great minds think alike, Mogsy:)).
I’m going with the Siberian cover. The Orbit covers were a close second.
It’s a proper old-school space opera cover, isn’t it, Laura? I really liked it, too…
I like the 2018 Polish edition.
I’m glad it’s got some love, Jennie:). Thank you for swinging by.
I’m glad, too. 🙂 You’re welcome, Sarah.
I love the first one too. It’s definitely the one that consistently caught my eye as I scrolled through the choices several times. I love the dramatic effect and the vibrant colors. I didn’t even mind the quote from George R.R. Martin at the top, lol.
Yes – and in the end, that’s what I had to do, too! Normally, I find it far easier to choose my favourite, but this week it ended up being very, very close…
The original Orbit cover is my favorite – and the one on the e-book I own, so it’s natural that I would be more attracted to it. And what a joy to see one of my beloved Expanse books showcased!!!! 🙂
Yes! I have only read the first two books in this series and really enjoyed them, but I have to be in a particular frame of mind to relish epic space opera and I will now probably wait until next summer to see if I feel like catching up with it, then:))
Pingback: #SciFiMonth Mission Status: week two
Great choice this week! There are a lot of great covers, but I think I like the last one best.
Thank you, Brittany – yes, this week there were a few I really liked.
How on earth did I miss this! Anyway, I have to agree with your choice – it’s a great cover.
Thank you! Himself and I have had quite a big argument over my favourite – he reckons it’s a rubbish design *huff* the cheeck!!.
Aw, I like the tentacle one! The first one’s very dramatic and colorful, true, but I do love the unearthly feel of that third one…
I know! It’s a bit of a struggle to choose, isn’t it?
I like the original edition (Italian feels like badly cropped ripoff 😉 ), but I’m a fan of Dark Crayon’s designs, so my vote goes for Polish ones. While I agree with the text disappearing in a small size, books in Poland are mostly sold as paperbacks/hardbacks (ebook market is tiny), so the concern is to be eye-catching on the store’s bookshelf, and I think with its start contrast and clarity, the cover does it well.
Plus MAG is known for “pretty” hardback editions more than mass market multi-sellers, and Dark Crayon (the cover’s author) has a specific style, and sometimes the effect seems more important than readbility. For example, his collector editions of Gaiman’s short stories are completely unreadable text-wise, but soooooo pretty and definitely “collector worthy”…:
I guess I should stop defending the Polish cover… 😉
Lol… No, no! It’s really helpful to get some context:)). If this is the print version, then I need to pay more attention – because the publisher won’t necessarily be thinking of the cover in thumbnail!