This meme was started by Books by Proxy, whose fabulous idea was to compare UK and US book covers and decide which is we prefer. This meme is now being nurtured by Lynn’s Book Blog and this week we have been given the chance to feature whatever we like. I’ve gone for a wonderful science fiction read about an autistic young man set in the future called The Speed of Dark by Elizabeth Moon…
This edition was produced by Del Rey in June 2005 and is a real contender. I love the image of the haunted-looking young man – the blurring effect of the light and the quirky positioning of the title. My main grizzle is the chatter in the bottom left of the cover which I think compromises the design, though at least it has been positioned with some thought.
Published in May 2004 by Ballantine Books, this Tenth Anniversary edition is another effective cover. The interlocking pieces making up the whole image, which is still off-centre creates an eye-catching, arresting effect. However, the title font is underpowered and boring, while that ugly textbox is completely out of place, especially given the strong colour draws the eye away from the otherwise muted design palette.
This offering, published by Ballentine Books in March 2004, is the least successful effort. The child’s windmill is evidently supposed to look as if it’s spinning at speed, but ends up looking like a poorly executed blur. This effect is emphasised in thumbnail, where the binary sequencing manages to make the whole cover look out of focus. I don’t like the limp title and author fonts, or the chatter cluttering up the design, either. A book this awesome deserves a far better cover.
This next cover was released in December 2010 by Hachette. I love the drama of the splinters of light flying off across the cover, while the dark purple corona against the black background looks beautiful. This cover certainly stands out from the others with the sheer visual drama. For once, both the title and author fonts are substantial enough to stand out from the design to be easily read, which surely ought to be their purpose, anyhow. This is my favourite.
This Polish hardback edition, released in May 2005 by ISA, is also a contender. I love the purple image of the young man with the silvered eyes, while the play of light in the background is beautiful and eye-catching. This one was so very nearly my favourite – which is yours?
I so love this book and so don’t love any of these covers! The Hachette one is the best of the bunch and the pinwheel is just awful. Good choice of book though. I think everyone should read this.
x The Captain
I know what you mean about the book – it’s the main reason why I chose it. A fabulous, fabulous book:))
Ya, the font is unattractive on all of them. Your choice is great but I think I like the first cover. I’m guessing you chose it because you liked the story. Thanks for sharing!
Oh yes – the story is fabulous. An amazing read, Jackie:)
Gosh, what a range of different covers for this one book! Given that I don’t find myself drawn to sci fi very often these daysI love the second cover down. It really draws me to want to read the book and it doesn’t scream sci fi to me. Having said that the first cover is the most stunning of them all.
It’s a wonderful book, Hayley. I think it has far wider appeal than just for sci fi fans…
It was really hard to choose. All of them are good. But, I’m going with your choice. It reaches out to me the most.
It’s the drama of those flying sparks that I love… have you read this one, Laura? I think you’d love it:)
I would be most apt to pick up the second one. Notice how the word “The” was dropped from the title in the version you chose?
I hadn’t picked up on that! I do recall having to check twice with Goodreads that I’d got the title right, as I kept wanting to drop ‘The’ – so on one level I’d noticed it… And Himself hadn’t noticed it either! You are clearly someone who pays attention to details:)).
My “day job” involves editing online content, so I suppose that type of thing pops out at me.
Ah… now that explains it:)).
Love the tenth anniversary edition! I agree it is very effective!
Thank you, Mogsy. Have you read this one?
I almost entirely agree with you about these covers. The Hachette cover has the most impact and is the least cluttered, and the ISA cover’s orange title cover does clash badly. The only place where I’d disagree is that I consider the Ballantine cover the worst, as it manages to be simultaneously dull and disjointed — absolutely godawful.
Thank you! I’ll stick to my guns regarding the worst as I LOATHE that wretched child’s windmill – apart from anything else, I think also manages to be condescending as the protagonist isn’t a child, he’s a young man… Though perhaps I’m giving the cover art designer too much credit – they probably haven’t read it, anyway:)
The first cover is the one I like best, and I can ignore the writing on the lower left corner if I focus on the image and the colors… More important, since I liked Moon’s Vatta series, I’m adding this title to my “wanted” list for future… explorations 🙂
This one is different to her space operas, but is regarded as a classic. It’s so GOOD:))
Noted! 🙂
Thank you!
The cover of the splintered-light purple one is the one I’d reach for.
Isn’t it just beautiful? Thank you for taking part, Rae:)
I think I like the last one. I like the colour and the face.
Yes… it is beautiful, isn’t it? If I wasn’t such a pushover for bright, sparking lights, that might well have been my favourite.
I like the one you picked and I also like the second one, mainly just because I’m drawn to the black and white (minus the red banner running across it though).
Yes – that banner really does compromise that cover, doesn’t it?
Yep, I love your favourite Sarah, it jumped out at me immediately before I scrolled back and read your thoughts.
Lynn 😀
Thank you, Lynn – glad you play the same game on my site that I play with yours… Picking my favourite before reading your opinion:))