I was delighted to see this offering on Netgalley, having only recently had the pleasure of reading the previous book, The Liar in the Library – see my review here. So I was still in the groove with the Fethering regulars, as well as easily able to recall the foibles of the main protagonists, Jude and Carol.
Although she hadn’t known Leonard Mallett very well, nor liked him particularly, Carole Seddon feels duty bound to attend her fellow committee member’s funeral. As she suspected, the hymns, readings and sermon are all very predictable — not unlike Leonard himself. What she couldn’t have predicted was that the deceased’s daughter would use the occasion to publicly accuse her stepmother of murder. Did Heather Mallett really kill her husband, as many Fethering residents believe? Deciding to get to the heart of the matter, Carole’s neighbour Jude joins the new community choir – and discovers that amidst the clashing egos and petty resentments lurk some decidedly false notes. At least one chorister would appear to be hiding a deadly secret — and it’s up to Carole and Jude to unearth the truth.
What I particularly enjoy about this series, is that while the murder investigation is the engine that powers the plot, Brett also gives us a real slice of life within the Fethering community. We get an insight into what matters to this community – both good and bad – and Brett isn’t afraid to take a pop at the frailties of the characters he depicts. There is an edge to his observations and I enjoy seeing how he plays with our assumptions – and then throws in a twist, such as the fact that buttoned-up Carol previously had a fling with the village landlord. In fact, I don’t particularly like Carol, whose self-righteous, rather jealous behaviour frankly gets on my nerves – however those traits help to make her effective at worrying at a mystery until she has solved it to her satisfaction. It certainly doesn’t impact on my enjoyment, as her rather jaundiced, sour observations are also insightful and rather funny – and while I don’t like her, I do like the more easy-going, relaxed Jude.
I found this investigation even more enjoyable than the previous one – there were several real surprises that had me reading far into the night to find out what was going to happen next. I’d figured out what happened and why – until the denouement, when I realised that I’d got it completely wrong. Nonetheless, despite my complete misreading of the situation, the perpetrator and the reasons for the wicked deed made absolute sense – and the clues were there. In short, Brett writes a cracking whodunit with a very well-plotted mystery which is a joy to read.
I haven’t read all nineteen of these entertaining books – but given just how much I have enjoyed these last two, I am definitely going to be visiting Fethering again. This series is far too much fun to miss out on. While I obtained an arc of The Killer in the Choir from Netgalley, the opinions I have expressed are unbiased and my own.
8/10
Brainfluff 
It sounds like these are all independent stories, which is good. When I saw Book 19 I was a little worried! Glad you enjoyed it😁
Oh yes – each book is a complete standalone and can be read as such.
So, 19 books – and are all these murder mysteries taking place in Fethering – people better start moving out, sounds a risky place to live. In fairness, I’m always on the look out for a good murder mystery and these do sound entertaining. I’ll have to keep a note of this author – particularly as the books can be read as standalones.
lynn 😀
Well… Fethering and surrounding area – Brett has based the area on my locality, given that he lives just up the road, and I can vouch for the fact that we haven’t had a crime spree on this scale since I’ve lived here:))
Ah, these delightful country villages, with their manicured gardens in front and murder plots in the back! 😀 😀
Oh absolutely, Maddalena:))
This sounds like such a fun series, and I like that it sounds like the books will work as standalones.
Oh yes! Brett is a very experienced author, who is capable of producing a strong overarching narrative arc while ensuring each story works on its own.
it sounds like a fun read, and I’ve told you before, I love twists and turns!
Oh this one is full of twists and turns, Rae:)
As a member of our church’s choir, I can toooootally relate to all the goofy drama that plays out behind the music. 🙂 I also find it interesting that one of the main characters is NOT a likable person; I think too often writers feel like the one readers follow HAS to be the character readers like. Not so!