I spotted this one on several book blogging sites I respect, but when Lynn at Lynn’s Book Blog featured it as one of her upcoming reads, I scampered across to Netgalley and managed to get approved for it. And we agreed to buddy read it…
Sancia Grado is a thief, and a damn good one. And her latest target, a heavily guarded warehouse on Tevanne’s docks, is nothing her unique abilities can’t handle. But unbeknownst to her, Sancia’s been sent to steal an artifact of unimaginable power, an object that could revolutionize the magical technology known as scriving. The Merchant Houses who control this magic–the art of using coded commands to imbue everyday objects with sentience–have already used it to transform Tevanne into a vast, remorseless capitalist machine. But if they can unlock the artifact’s secrets, they will rewrite the world itself to suit their aims. Now someone in those Houses wants Sancia dead, and the artifact for themselves. And in the city of Tevanne, there’s nobody with the power to stop them…
Part of the rather chatty blurb above makes it clear the magic system is complex with a long, involved history. Back at the height of a lost civilisation, the ancients were able to wield magic to do unimaginable things and it is the discovery of some of their magical objects that has allowed the brightest minds to work out how to rekindle magical power, albeit in a bastardised form. It is the discovery of this magic powering the rise of the four merchanting families, who have a stranglehold on Tevanne. Furthermore, those who are not born into the service of these houses, or are thrown away after they have outlived their usefulness, scrabble for survival in the Commons. And there’s Sancia, whose backstory is different again…
I loved the premise and the world. It seems entirely plausible that a capitalist system would reward those with the magical skills and artefacts, while neglecting those who aren’t so fortunate. Sancia is a brilliant protagonist – one of the best I have read this year. Gritted, determined and focused on surviving, with a special ability that she would love to lose, she is a thief. Bennett writes her ability brilliantly and I found myself engrossed in her plight.
So I was more than a tad fed up when the action scenes were halted by chunks of explanation of how the magic works in omniscient point of view. The most egregious example occurs about halfway through the book during a fight – where the courageous hero is left hanging in mid-realisation that his attackers are flying, while we break off for a detailed explanation as to why flying is technically a really tricky business and therefore illegal… It was the only sheer quality of the writing and characters saved the book from flying across the room at this point. I would prefer an appendix where the magic system is explained in detail for those who like drilling into such details of the worldbuilding, rather than crashing across the story so intrusively.
Rant aside, this book is a joy. Fortunately the info-dumps decrease significantly in the second half of the book, allowing the pace to pick up. The world is well described and the characters gripped me – I like the fact that despite the patriarchy running Tevanne, there are plenty of strong, not necessarily likeable female characters who punch through the institutional obstacles in their path. But the character who shines through all of this is Sancia – I dreamt of her… Damaged, scarred and struggling with mental issues, she is still battling to move forward and strive for something better. The climax works brilliantly and I liked the ending, which nicely sets this one up for the sequel, which I look forward to reading.
Highly recommended for those who enjoy detailed, urban fantasy tales peopled with awesome characters – if that appendix was in place this book would have scored a 10. While I obtained an arc of Foundryside from the publisher via Netgalley, the opinions I have expressed are unbiased and my own.
I’m glad you enjoyed it, info dumping aside😊 Regarding your example above, either it didnt bother me, or he did it so skillfully that I didn’t even notice. Or maybe I didn’t care that the character was hanging from the roof because the explanation was so interesting to me😁
Oh I loved it, aside from the info dumping… Though it is something I really, really mind about, which is why I expect I particularly noticed it. I think it depended also on whether the explanation really interests the reader. To be honest, after the first couple of examples, explaining how it worked, I didn’t really care all that much – I just wanted the story to roll forward. And that’s the difference – some of us are alll about the characters and story and some of us mind a bit more about the worldbuilding underpinning that… But you’re right – I’m so glad I’ve read this one, particularly as he is clearly a very talented, inventive author:))
Pingback: Foundryside (Founders #1) by Robert Jackson Bennett | Books and travelling with Lynn
Fantastic review! That first warehouse scene is pretty darn good!
Oh yes – and I really loved the book – don’t get me wrong:)).
Oh no, I understand.
I’m already looking forward to the second one.
I am thinking I should read this 🙂
I am conscious that I am an outlier – most folks who read this book rave about it. And I almost do, but am a bit more bugged abut the info-dumps than the majority.
Neat that the world was so detailed and that you enjoyed it. I can definitely see why you would. 🙂
And the characterisation is fabulous, while the story is gripping and plausible.
LOL Glad you didn’t throw the book! And it sounds like it turned out well once ou got past the info dumps.
Yes – I’m glad I didn’t chuck the book across the room, too. Especially as it was on my Kindle… And it really is a cracking read, which was one reason why I found the info dumps so annoying – and I’m also aware that most readers didn’t find it the problem that I did.
Just started this one yesterday and I’m excited to read more. I love seeing all the positive reviews of this one so far!
I hope you love it – other than the info dumps, I thought it was brilliant.
Great review, and I appreciate your take on infodumps… I’m just struggling myself to decide how to put mine :D. Appendix at the end is probably a great idea, the way Sarah Dunant does it with many of her historical fiction novels. You can always learn from other genres…!
Thank you, Steph:). Have you read this one? It is a cracking book, but too much of the detail wasn’t immediately necessary for the action on that particular page – and that’s when I think an appendix really comes in handy…
On my TBR. I’ll let you know as soon as I am done 🙂
Looking forward to hearing what you think of it, Steph.
The premise of this one is irresistible, but the info dumps are a bit off putting. I am glad you enjoyed this one even so, Sarah. I will definitely have to check it out.
Yes – though despite the info dumps it is STILL an awesome read.
Oh yay, I’ve been waiting to see what you thought of Foundryside. Wasn’t Sancia just the best protagonist? I really loved her. I definitely agree with you about the info dumping. If not for that, this would have easily been a 5 star read for me.
Yes! Sancia is certainly one of my favourite protagonists of the year so far:))
It’s a great start to series and hopefully now that we’ve established certain things the info dumps will lighten a little in the next book. I loved Sancia and the magic system is really clever – so I can understand the author being really enthusiastic about it, but like you, it did pull me out of the action a little at certain points at the beginning.
It is a remarkable series – and I’m definitely up for reading the next one. I agree with your comments regarding the magic and Sancia:)
Looks like a great read, and I like the Sancia character.
I so agree with you about the benefits of appendix. It is boring to get interrupted in the middle of action 🙂
Yes – it was a shame. Though I’m conscious that I do have a bit of a bee in my bonnet about such things…
Appendix is a place of reference for me when I suddenly get lost 🙂 Love the maps too 🙂
Yes! Maps are really helpful when getting your bearings in a constructed world – I always draw rough ones when writing sci fi and fantasy, even if it’s only a plan of the space ship…
The cover got my attention when I saw it in your Teaser Tuesday post, and the review got me excited… until I saw the rant part of it. Interesting enough, I still want to read it though!