Review of NETGALLEY arc The Cottingley Secret by Hazel Gaynor


I’m not normally a fan of long blurbs, but this one manages to neatly sum up a fairly complex story without giving away any major spoilers, so for once, I’m not going to prune it…

1917… It was inexplicable, impossible, but it had to be true—didn’t it? When two young cousins, Frances Griffiths and Elsie Wright from Cottingley, England, claim to have photographed fairies at the bottom of the garden, their parents are astonished. But when one of the great novelists of the time, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, becomes convinced of the photographs’ authenticity, the girls become a national sensation, their discovery offering hope to those longing for something to believe in amid a world ravaged by war. Frances and Elsie will hide their secret for many decades. But Frances longs for the truth to be told.

One hundred years later… When Olivia Kavanagh finds an old manuscript in her late grandfather’s bookshop she becomes fascinated by the story it tells of two young girls who mystified the world. But it is the discovery of an old photograph that leads her to realize how the fairy girls’ lives intertwine with hers, connecting past to present, and blurring her understanding of what is real and what is imagined. As she begins to understand why a nation once believed in fairies, can Olivia find a way to believe in herself?

And there you have it. Two timelines interweaving throughout the story with the major protagonists being young, dreamy Frances, displaced and pining for her father during the long war years. And dreamy, older Olivia, also somehow displaced from her own life after devastating news leaves her questioning everything and everyone in her life so far – and find it wanting.

The real challenge of writing such a book is to adequately balance both story strands so the reader isn’t rushing through one to get back to the other. And in this case, Gaynor has succeeded beautifully. At no stage did I find myself skim-reading through any section to get to another – despite skimming being one of my vices as a reader. So it is a tribute to the quality of Gaynor’s characterisation that both the lonely little girl and isolated twenty-something equally held me.

The other temptation in a story of this nature – particularly this specific story, given the scads that has already been written and said about it – is to either sensationalise or sentimentalise what occurred. Again, I admire Gaynor’s restraint – she could have revelled in the fuss and fame those photographs generated and allowed that to power the narrative. However, she also resisted that temptation, too. So what we have is a beautifully told tale of two hurt, sensitive people seeking refuge in something else outside their daily round. One of the joys of this book is that Gaynor’s writing has a lyrical quality that makes her descriptions of that small brook where Frances played alongside her fairies sing off the page. While her descriptions of the old, second-hand bookshop is equally vivid, so that I not only visualised the shop, I could smell the books, too.

When two narrative timelines run alongside each other, the other imperative is that the ending has to connect them to the readers’ satisfaction – and once again, Gaynor triumphantly succeeds in doing this. It isn’t a fantasy or paranormal tale, or a historical adventure – neither is it a contemporary romance, but it manages to interleave all these aspects into a wonderful, unusual story and is recommended for anyone who enjoys any of the above.

22 responses »

  1. So sorry I could not get back to your blog until now. Many things happened during this time, but the best thing was your book 🙂 You told me that your readers like the second book more than the first one, and I think I know why ( I love both books though!) In the first book your heroine is very young; in the second book she has a different kind of experiences and gets involved in the complex affairs of Restormel. But without the book #1 her portrait is incomplete.
    Thank you for writing great books, and I look forward to reading about Elizabeth’s future adventures.

  2. Such a lovely review for what sounds like an enchanting story. I’ve read other books about this incident and would like to read this one too.

  3. Different timelines woven into the same story are one of my favorite tropes, and when they are done well – as it would seem they are in this novel – they make for a fast-paced, breathless reading. And this story sounds quite fascinating, as well…
    Thank you so much for sharing! 🙂

    • It has been done really well, though I wouldn’t describe this book as a fast-paced read. There is quite a lot of description and the pace is quite leisurely. But the narrative steadily builds to an engrossing read.

  4. This sounds like a gorgeous read. I love dual timeline stories anyway and I like the idea that it contains elements of so many different types of novels. That cover is beautiful too. It made me think of The Secret Garden when I first glanced at it. Wonderful review. You’ve convinced me I need to read this book. 🙂

  5. That sounds interesting how those two timelines combine in the book. And indeed with such a story it’s important both storylines are interesting, so you arne’t just rushing to get back to the one you like better. That’s awesome the author succeeded with that. It does sound like a wonderful read and I am glad to hear you enjoyed this one.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.